The band started about five years ago between Sly and his friends, including Tyler as their bassist at the time, when they produced four songs, including Make This Your Dance Floor which was used in Sly's intros and got the band into the internet limelight. The band went into a hiatus for a while but reformed again, taking on Aleks (ImmortalHD) to replace Tyler and recording new songs. In February 2012, the band released their first digital EP: self-titled and featuring 6 songs.
In late April of 2013, Sly released a Tumblr post regarding Stuck In Your Radio's new songs. It is said that they are hoping to release the 4 new songs by the end of this summer. (Unfortunately, the songs have not yet been released and any of the band members have yet to give word on the progress.)They also have a series on Sly's channel called "SIYR Plays" where they will play various games. The first game in the series was "New Super Mario Bros. Wii".